Judging Criteria

For each entry, judges will evaluate the overall quality of the piece based on the qualities below. They will also take into consideration the Design Brief submitted. Each category will be rated on a scale of 1-10 for a total of 6-60 points.

  • Creativity/Originality
  • Composition
  • Quality of Messaging
  • Marketing Impact
  • Visual Design
  • Use of Medium

Student entries will be judged separately, using the same criteria.


Award Guidelines
Best of Show: The highest scored entry will receive this award.
Best Student of Show:  The highest scored student entry will receive this award.
Gold Award: Entries with a score of 50 to 60 points
Silver Award: Entries with a score of 45-49 points
Honorable Mention: Entries with an average score of 40-44 points.


Scoring Standards

It is the goal of AIGA Alaska to elevate design in Alaska, that’s why we intentionally select national and internationally recognized judges. We expect them to be tough. We ask them to be tough. Their opinion reflects current design standards on a global level. Scoring is based on a 10–point scale. Each judge will assign a score to each category, and all scores will be averaged to determine an entry’s final score.

10: Clearly excellent work. Best of the best. No weak spots.

9: Extremely fine work. However, missing some quality that would make it exceptional.

8: Overall very good. May have one weakness but makes a highly favorable impression.

6–7: Acceptable, solid work.

1–5: Average or below average work.